Best Pizzas in Evanston (Part One)

Best Pizza in Evanston

There is no shortage of excellent pizza places in the Evanston area. Whether you like classic Chicago deep dish or you prefer your pies a little lighter, you’ll be able to find something you love at one of these top-notch pizza spots.


Lou Malnati’s is a favorite among locals. It is known for their ultra-satisfying deep-dish pies with a rich, buttery crust. Choose one of their classics, like the Lou, or build your own. They have thin crust options, as well as pastas, salads and more. The cozy indoor space is a great place to watch the game or kick back with your family.


The excellent local gem is tucked away in a strip mall.  Unlike many other area classics, they specialize in thin crust Neapolitan pizzas, which have fluffy but charred crusts. They also serve a full menu of pastas and other Italian classics. Pizza purists can also choose from classic Chicago, New York, or New Haven style pizzas.


If you’re looking to treat yourself to some excellent takeout, Sarpino’s has a full menu of inventive comfort foods, including pizzas, calzones, pastas and even wings. They’re known for their creative specialty pizzas. Some of their most inventive options include Tropical Hawaiian, Canadian Classic, Super Taco and Grecian Gyro.


Giordano’s is world-famous for their Chicago style deep dish pizza. This has been one of the best places to get an old-school pie since the 1970s. While it’s great for takeout, their cozy diner space also makes it an excellent choice for a dinner out. They have a full menu of classic Italian appetizers and entrees, as well as beer and wine.


Union Pizzeria is known for their light but satisfying Neapolitan pies, as well as their stylish space, which has a hip warehouse feel. In addition to their pizzas and other Italian-inspired dishes, Union has a full menu of beer, wine and cocktails. They also host a Sunday brunch, where you can enjoy breakfast favorites, in addition to their classic pizzas.


This cozy spot brings an authentic Italian feel to Evanston. Their main attraction is their wood-fired pizzas, but they also have a full menu of classic pastas and even authentic Italian desserts, like cannoli and tiramisu. In the warmer months, patrons can dine al fresco on their small street patio.


Stop into Gigio’s for a casual lunch or dinner and prepare to enjoy a full menu of comfort food classics. They serve New York style thin crust pizzas, which you can also purchase by the slice. They also serve tacos, hamburgers and subs, so there are several excellent options for those who are want something different. Gigio’s is a fixture in the Evanston community. They have been around since 1968.


Blaze Pizza is a trendy fast casual chain. Their build your own pizza model allows you to choose your toppings on classic thin crust pizzas. You can complete your meal with a salad or classic garlic knots, or even a rich chocolate dessert. They have a cute, casual space with both indoor and outdoor seating for those who want to dine in.


This classic American restaurant is housed in a historic former firehouse. It has a relaxed pub vibe where you can enjoy a game of billiards, watch a sports game and sip on your favorite brew while enjoying your pizza. They serve a rich and satisfying pan pizza, as well as American classics like burgers, fried chicken, steak and wings.


Ten Mile House is a sleek and stylish New American spot that offers many delicious foods. They serve delectable hand-tossed wood-fired pizzas, and you can build your own pizza by selecting a sauce, cheeses and other toppings.  There are also plenty of smoked meats as well as classic sandwiches on the menu.


Papa John’s is a nationwide favorite that is conveniently located in downtown Evanston. Order takeout and delivery for a night in – they have pizzas as well as classic breadsticks and wings. Their signature pizzas are Sicilian style, although they also offer Midwestern pan pizzas.


Rosati’s is another Chicago classic that is known for their deep-dish pizza. They have recently opened an Evanston location where you can order their great pies. They also serve authentic Chicago sandwiches, salads and pastas.


Bob’s Pizza is the new kid on the block in Evanston. It serves a unique style of pizza that has a thick, chewy crust and quality toppings. Unique specialty options like sweet corn and lobster, pickle pizza, and wild mushroom make this an ideal place to venture out of your comfort zone.